Guest Column: Consider issues, not emotions, in Wis. recall election
June 28, 2011
On June 8, Wisconsin’s Government
Accountability Board approved the recall elections for three of
nine Democratic state senators. The recall approval
follows the senators’ flight to Illinois during the tumultuous
negotiations over Governor Walker’s budget bill.<span style=
“mso-spacerun: yes;”> Six Republican state senators joined
the fleeing senators. These six were targeted because of their
support for the budget repair bill.
That bill’s most controversial section imposed
sizeable limitations on collective bargaining for state employees.
Teachers stood to be the most severely affected by these
limitations. At the time the budget was under
consideration, media members swarmed to the Capitol in Madison,
which had quickly crowded with protesters. While
media attention has since shifted to other matters, the issue
persists.
The recall election primaries are set for July
12 for the Republican senators and July 19 for the Democratic
senators. The race during
which both will run against each other will be held August
16.
With the dates of the recall elections fast
approaching, Wisconsinites must ask themselves for whom they plan
to vote. I ask the
constituents of my district, as well as those from others, to pause
for a moment and consider the situation from a variety of
viewpoints.
On one hand, the flight of Senators Dave
Hansen, D-Green Bay, Jim Holperin, D-Conover, and Bob Wirch,
D-Pleasant Prairie, to Illinois was cowardly and
immature. Instead of facing opposition, gathering
support against the bill from constituents and representing their
districts with strength, integrity and honor, they fled to an
out-of-state water park. Their stunt was reminiscent of the tactics
small children use to evade baths and bedtime.
Since the senators failed to forestall the
passage of the budget they opposed, their retreat was as fruitless
as it was childish. Because they
were absent during a time of crisis, these senators could
not be the strong leaders their constituents elected them to
be. These senators failed those constituents so thoroughly
that voters might well be inclined to support their
recall.
Of course, disappointed constituents won’t be
the only ones who favor their recall.<span style=
“mso-spacerun: yes;”> Support for it can be expected from
more conservative voters as well, on the basis of their policy
disagreements with incumbents. Though Gov. Walker’s
poll numbers are sagging, there is a chance that a Republican
senator will still be elected. The success of the Marinette Marine
Corporation (though it was an initiative of Herb Kohl rather than
Scott Walker), seems to have proven to many members of the public
that the governor is making good on his promise of jobs and
“opening Wisconsin for business.”
On the other hand, Sen. Hansen has
consistently voted along Democratic Party lines, and recently voted
against the voter ID bill when most of the other Democrats chose to
abstain. Hansen has represented Green Bay’s constituents well in
the past. Keeping a strong Democratic presence in the
Senate might be an excellent idea when Wisconsin’s state senate is
already conservative. We wouldn’t want a homogeneous
Senate now, would we? <span style=
“mso-spacerun: yes;”> Variety is what makes America what it
is — “the melting pot,” as School House Rock would put it.
The Democrats fled because
they wanted more time to find a way to prevent passage of this
disastrous bill. Was it a poor decision? Of course. But their
hearts were in the right places, and they continue to strongly
oppose the bills put forth by the more conservative members of the
Senate.
Citizens living in these recall districts
should pay close attention and take time to vote, even amid the
lazy haze of summer.