Barefoot: Abortion on TV
January 7, 2011
Did you miss the special MTV did on
teen abortions called “<a href=
“http://www.mtv.com/shows/no_easy_decision/series.jhtml”>No Easy
Decision” during winter break? You probably did, considering
MTV did not promote the special that aired after the “16 and
Pregnant” reunion special in any way whatsoever. They even put the
special in the after hours graveyard spot of 11:30 p.m. eastern
time.
So what’s the big deal? Well, the fact
that it wasn’t promoted or advertised gives in to the popular idea
that having an abortion is something not to be talked about and
something to be ashamed of. If their own network is afraid to
tackle promoting this difficult subject, how are women who had
abortion supposed to feel?
The stand alone special featured three
teens — including <a href=
“http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/16_And_Pregnant#Season_3”>Markai,
who gave birth to another child on the show “16 and Pregnant” — and
their decision to terminate their pregnancies and the emotional
aftermath. While the special did a good job showing abortion in a
fair light, the lack of promotion hurt its chance to be helpful to
teens struggling with abortion decisions.
Nearly one-third of all teen
pregnancies end in abortion, according to the <a href=
“http://www.guttmacher.org/index.html”>Guttmacher Institute,
yet “16 and Pregnant” does not feature any teens who chose this
option. Then again, this is the same show where very few mothers
have chosen to give up their child for adoption. What does it say
when a “reality” TV show refuses to show all of the options, mainly
abortion?
On the “16 and Pregnant” reunion
special that was aired before “No Easy Decision,” <a href=
“http://www.realitybitesbackbook.com/2010/12/29/liveblogging-16-pregnant-reunion-and-mtv-abortion-special-no-easy-decision/”>
Markai talked with Dr. Drew about life after her baby was born.
Not once was her abortion discussed at all, but was the main story
on the special. Even when discussing birth control and plans for
having another child, her abortion was ignored.
Of course the reunion was highly
publicized on MTV and was expected to have a high viewership,
unlike “No Easy Decision” which you watched only if you stayed long
enough after the reunion to care.
MTV isn’t the only one to shy away
from the abortions. Movies such as “Juno“,
“Knocked Up” and “Waitress” all feature unplanned pregnancies but
talk little about abortion or use the word. In “Knocked Up” it is
called “taking care of it” or a “Rhymes with Susmortion.” In
“Waitress” it was simply “the other thing” In “Juno,” Juno goes to
the clinic for one, only to be change her mind when learning the
baby has fingernails.
Even in the ever cheesy Canadian Show
“<a href=
“http://www.tv.com/degrassi-the-next-generation/accidents-will-happen-2/episode/278924/summary.html”>Degrassi” when
they did an abortion two-part episode, the American
channel The
N, refused to show it due to it controversial content. This
same network had no problem showing teen pregnancy, drinking, STDs,
school shootings, but abortion is controversial. Especially since
the show has many plots dealing with sexuality that puts characters
with an unplanned pregnancy.
Why is it that while <a href=
“http://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/html/historics/USSC_CR_0410_0113_ZS.html”>Roe
v. Wade case decision turns 38 this month, that abortion is
still looked down upon, or not talked about at all in
television?
Why is the media so scared to show
abortion as a reasonable choice for women? Sure it is
controversial, and not a simple choice to make, but it is
happening. By not publicizing it doesn’t mean abortion will
magically go away.
TV seems to feature abortion plots
more than movies, but never in an even slightly positive light. If
a character does have an abortion or is thinking about on in a
movie or television show, there are several options for her:
1. She magically miscarries before she
has an abortion such as on “Dawson’s Creek” and “Beverly Hill’s
90210.”
Because while miscarriage does happen,
there is a slim chance that by wishing you don’t want the baby it
will magically happen.
2. She is very much distressed with
and turns to alcohol drugs or other bad behavior, or she dreams
about dead babies, like in “Six Feet Under.”
While I think it is safe to say that
abortion can cause emotional stress, it does not mean that all
women react the same way. So why does our media show only the worst
possible scenario?
3. You die. This occurs after the
abortion, when after backlash from people who find the plot
controversial and boycott your show and then screen writers decide
to kill off the character to appease them. This happened in the
short lived “<a href=
“http://www.thewb.com/shows/jack-and-bobby”>Jack and
Bobby” series.
Because higher forces will punish you
by death for having an abortion regardless if you believe in them.
I’m sure Planned Parenthood says otherwise.
4. At the last possible minute she
will change her mind and keep the baby. Naturally everything is
turns out okay, such as in a plot in “Sex and the City” and more
recently “Private Practice” and the god awful “<a href=
“http://jezebel.com/5021103/the-not+so+secret-pro+life-message-of-the-secret-life-of-the-american-teenager”>Secret
Life of the American Teenager.”
While abortion is not the right choice
for everyone, these shows send the message that it’s not the right
choice for anyone.
“<a href=
“http://www.nytimes.com/2010/07/10/arts/television/10lights.html”>Friday
Night Lights” is the only show I can think of that recently did
a good job with this topic, with Becky clearly stating why she
wanted it. She was in the 10th grade with no money and knew she
couldn’t raise a child. After having the abortion she thought she
made the right choice. We shall see if screenwriters and
advertisers allow her to keep this decision.
In the 1970s, there was one show that
portrayed abortion in a fair light, “Maude.”
While Maude was
upset about it, she didn’t die, change her mind, or turn to drugs.
In the end she was okay with her decision and moved on. That was 30
years ago, and we have made little progress since then.
There might be more abortion friendly
plots I am missing considering I don’t spend all day watching TV,
but the fact is they are few in number, and if they are there they
are narrow in their views.
What do I want to see in 2011? An
abortion storyline on television portrayed in a fair light, where
while the decision was difficult they feel like they made the right
choice. Oh and for it to be shown at a decent hour.
What happened to the days where TV was
more progressive than the movies? Where they pushed the envelope on
what you can see on TV and were advocates for social change? It
seems now days they are too worried about backlash and loss of
advertisements dollars to do anything outside the box.