EDITORIAL: Release of Moore film appropriate
June 9, 2004
He may be the left’s Rush Limbaugh, but Michael Moore certainly
has something to say, or at least he has the right to, according to
the First Amendment. Luckily, two brothers agree with letting
political speech from both sides reach the masses.
Bob and Harvey Weinstein, who run Miramax Films, have reached an
agreement with parent company Disney to release Moore’s
anti-President Bush documentary, “Fahrenheit 9/11.” The newly
formed Fellowship Adventure Group, co-chaired by the brothers, is
among three distributors of the film, and the Weinsteins reportedly
will reimburse Disney for the $6 million spent on the film’s
production. Lions Gate and IFC Films are the other
distributors.
In May, Disney refused to distribute the film because of its
political nature. Michael Eisner, Disney’s chief executive, told
Miramax not to work on the movie because of its political content,
according to The New York Times. The film, which won the Palme d’Or
at the Cannes Film Festival in May, takes a controversial look at
the Bush administration’s dealings with terrorism, Saudi ties and
the Iraq war. It also takes a critical stance on the 2000 election
of Bush, who did not win the popular vote. Despite the prestigious
film honor, Disney still refused to release the movie.
After Disney announced it would not distribute the film, Moore
accused the company of yielding to political pressure from Bush’s
brother Jeb, the governor of Florida, regarding certain tax
interests the company has in the state. Disney denied the
charges.
Tax interests aside, Disney has every right to bow out of a film
that will have a sizable portion of the public upset by its
accusations and assumptions. As a private company, Disney must make
decisions that are in its best interests. Debatably, marketing a
highly controversial, political documentary while at the same time
promoting “The Princess Diaries 2” might not be a solid business
choice.
Moore (who never does anything without a bit of flair) is
certainly pleased his rhetoric will reach the public, and said in a
statement, “On behalf of my stellar cast — GW, Dick, Rummy, Condi
and Wolfie — we thank this incredible coalition of the willing for
bringing ‘Fahrenheit 9/11’ to the people.”
However, the people who deserve thanks are the Weinstein
brothers. Although “Fahrenheit 9/11” is unlikely to have a
significant effect on the 2004 election — mostly because the
majority of people who see the film are already predisposed to
agree with its conclusions — it is admirable that the Weinstein
brothers took the effort to make sure the film sees the light of
day, especially with mega-corporation Disney breathing down their
necks.