Act of peace untouched by media
September 20, 2001
I want to thank 60 Israeli teenagers. I want to express my
appreciation for their courage and for their honesty. All
Palestinians, and all those interested in the Middle East, also owe
these students gratitude.
According to a little-publicized news report entitled “Israeli
students say no to army” Sept. 6 on the BBC News Web site, about
60 Israeli teenagers sent an open and remarkably critical letter to
Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon. In the letter the students said
they would refuse service in the Palestinian territories.
It’s true that the rejection is a relatively uncommon occurrence for
Israeli youth to decline military service, something that is
compulsory for both men and women in Israel at the age of 18. But
that wasn’t all that caught my attention.
Their reason for refusing conscription, according to the BBC report
is that “to do so would be to carry our racist policies.”
The letter could not have come at a better time. Before last week’s
attacks, we were still thinking about the United Nations Racism
Conference and the United States’ embarrassing decision to pull
out. In the very week following the racism conference, the French
news agency reported these Israeli students had written the letter.
The BBC also carried the account in this small story on the web.
The report continues that the students criticized the “aggressive
policies pursued by the government and the army.”
Not only that, but the Israelis cite specific offenses in their letter to
the prime minister. According to the BBC, “the letter listed land
expropriation, demolition of houses, torture and executions without
trial, as crimes against Palestinians.”
The injustices listed by the students are nearly identical to those
grievances maintained by Palestinian activists and Israeli human
rights organizations for years.
To bring the matter in to broader perspective, in the nearly one year
since the Al-Aqsa Intifada started, only 22 Israelis have refused
military service in the Palestinian territories, a pacifist organization
stated in the BBC story. Two weeks ago, about 60 students had
united in their cause of nonviolence and collectively criticized the
Israeli government, something that has apparently been deemed
not newsworthy by the American media.
Astonishing as it may seem, these 60 Israeli youth accused their
government of the same harsh and oppressive practices they
denied, the primary reason the United States and Israel boycotted
the United Nations Conference on Racism.
One question comes immediately to mind: Why did that story not
appear in the U.S. media? The only place I could find this story
was a very brief report on the Web site of the British Broadcasting
Company.
It is a suspicious coincidence that at the very time Israel’s policies
and U.S. involvement were being questioned, the potentially
damning story of these students is “forgotten” by the mainstream
American media. Were there other forces of influence involved in
that decision?
Perhaps these 60 teenagers are able to contribute a side of the
story that is certainly worth listening to.
They have put themselves on the line and publicly opposed their
government’s policies at a time when it is very unpopular, even
dangerous to do so. They deserve to be welcomed and supported
by the people who believe in a nonviolent justice for all people of
the Holy Land.
Thank you, Israeli students. I appreciate your empathy for people
demanding equality and your courageous pursuit of justice.
Omar Tesdell is a sophomore in journalism and mass
communication from Slater. He is online editor of the Daily.