Cutting board

This one is a bit out there, but you’ll get points for being pretty unique. Most people don’t think of doing this as a gift, but there are still plenty of sites online that offer cutting board personalization services, such as Etsy or ThingsRemembered.com.

Plate

ThingsRemebered.com also has personalized plates, meaning the type of decorative, breakable plate you’d hang on your wall or on a stand. There are a lot of cool ideas of what to have printed on the plate, or you can go so far as to make it yourself.

Initial doormat

Everyone can use an updated doormat, so this gift is thoughtful and functional. Hit up PersonalizationMall.com or FrontGate.com/outdoor-decor for some ideas.

Etched mason jar mugs

GlassWithATwist.com and Etsy have some cool looking mason jars that have intitials and/or names etched into them. You can also do dates and graphics, or switch the vessel to a wine glass, mug, etc. Get creative and keep the couple in mind.

Family name sign

You’ll have a lot of options when getting into this gift. You can change the size, text, material, font and whatever else, so keep the couple’s interest in mind. If the couple is into rustic-type stuff, check out Jetmak Designs on Etsy. If they enjoy more contemporary stuff, hit up Houzz.com or CedarSign.com.

Creative gifts usually have so many options, and you almost always have the option to make it that much more special by doing it yourself. Don’t go with the traditional wedding registry-exclusive approach. Instead, get out there and put some thought and effort into your gift.